Alligator Reef
Island Living,
Steps from Duval.
Alligator Reef is a private first-floor suite within our historic 1930s Key West townhome at 419 Truman Avenue. Two queen bedrooms, one bathroom and a queen sleeper sofa comfortably accommodate up to six guests.
Enjoy a spacious private front porch, your own entrance, a fully equipped kitchen with granite countertops and a comfortable living room. Hardwood floors and an in-suite washer and dryer add the comforts of home, just steps from Duval Street.
Settle Into
Key West.
Relax inside with comfortable gathering spaces and a full kitchen, then step outside to enjoy the covered porch and laid-back atmosphere of Old Town Key West.
Relaxed Island Style.
Room to Stay Together.
Designed for an Easy Stay.
Make It the Lighthouse Group Suite.
Alligator Reef connects directly to American Shoal through private interior connecting doors. Reserve the two suites together as the Lighthouse Group Suite for a spacious four-bedroom, two-bath Key West retreat accommodating up to twelve guests.
EXPLORE THE LIGHTHOUSE GROUP SUITE →Everything You Need for Key West.
The Key West Lighthouse.
One of Key West's most recognizable landmarks is visible from the Lighthouse Suites Collection — a fitting backdrop for a stay in the heart of Old Town.
Your own retreat. A tropical place to gather.
Your suite is private. The outdoor spaces are shared exclusively with registered guests staying in the other Lighthouse Suites accommodations and are not open to the public. Enjoy two heated tropical pools, double chaise cabanas, in-pool loungers, a pergola lounge and fire pit, and an outdoor kitchen, bar and BBQ grill. Outdoor refrigerators, filtered water, an ice station, and pool towels from the towel huts make poolside days easy.
Arrive with ease.
Complimentary parking is available in shared, non-exclusive spaces along Eanes Lane. These street spaces are not individually assigned or reserved. Complimentary luggage storage is available before check-in and after check-out. A gated entrance and your private suite entrance make it easy to settle in.
View the property map & parking →A team within reach.
Our team visits regularly to care for the grounds, pools and common areas. No staff reside on the property, and assistance is available 24/7 by phone, text or messaging. A welcome book in your suite includes property information and local recommendations.
Make Old Town yours.
Restaurants, shops, galleries and attractions are within walking or biking distance. Golf cart rentals are available next door, and taxis and rideshares offer another way to explore. Our tucked-away setting is steps from Duval, so occasional neighborhood and nightlife sounds may be heard.
Explore the neighborhood →Make Alligator Reef Yours.
Alligator Reef •
2 Bedrooms •
1 Bath •
Sleeps Up to 6
419 Truman Avenue · Key West, Florida