Alligator Reef Lighthouse Suite

A stylish 2BR retreat in a renovated 1930s Key West gem. Sleeps 6, with private porch views of the Lighthouse & Duval St, just steps from two brand-new oasis pools.

Two-story mint green house with white trim and balconies, set against a sunset sky.
Cozy living room with gray sofa, two armchairs, and wooden coffee table. Beach-themed decor, including bird and sailboat paintings. Light-colored walls, hardwood floor, ceiling fan, and large windows with blinds.
Bathroom with a tiled shower area, white door, wall art, and a light switch.

Description

Bedroom with a king-sized bed, white bedding, two bedside tables with lamps, a window, and a fish artwork above the headboard.
A bottle of Mionetto Prosecco with two empty champagne flutes on a wooden tray in a kitchen with stainless steel appliances and wooden cabinets.

419 Truman 1F

6

3

1

2/1

The Alligator Reef Lighthouse Suite offers separate King and Queen bedrooms that was completely refurbished in 2024 that can sleep up to 6 guests. This beautifully appointed ground floor suite, located in a renovated 1930’s Historic Key West building, offers a private exterior entrance and a spacious private front porch with Key West Lighthouse and partial Duval Street views tucked away on a quiet Key West Lane. The Suite is located steps away from the two brand new oasis pools and brand-new amenities on the property.

The Alligator Reef Lighthouse Suite offers the perfect blend of convenience and tranquility, located just a half-block from world-famous Duval Street. While you’re steps away from the vibrant energy of Key West’s best shops, restaurants, and nightlife, the resort is tucked away on a peaceful, picturesque lane, providing a quiet retreat. The iconic Hemingway House Museum, just behind the property, is only a 2-minute walk away, and Fort Zachary Taylor Park and Beach are also within easy walking distance. Experience the best of both worlds—close to the action, yet an oasis of peace and quiet.

Video Showcase

Guest Resources

1.jpg
2.jpg
3.jpg
4.jpg
5.jpg
6.jpg
7.jpg
8.jpg
9.jpg
10.jpg
11.jpg
12.jpg
13.jpg
14.jpg
15.jpg
16.jpg
17.jpg
18.jpg
19.jpg
20.jpg
21.jpg
22.jpg
23.jpg
24.jpg
25.jpg
26.jpg
27.jpg
28.jpg
29.jpg
30.jpg
31.jpg
32.jpg
33.jpg
34.jpg
35.jpg
36.jpg

Villa amenities

Illustration of various furniture items and a beverage container including a TV, bathtub, microwave, sofa, bed, and bottle, with numbers 1 through 6 beneath each item.

Serene sophistication with natural finishes

Simple icons of a house, a washing machine, and a delivery truck with a cardboard box.

    • 2 Luxury queen beds with premium linens 

    • Queen sleeper sofa

    • Equipped kitchen with granite countertops

    • Spa quality stone rain shower bathroom

    • Hardwood flooring throughout the suite

    • Spacious front porch with lighthouse and partial Duval St. views

    • Smart TVs with the latest Roku device for apps and streaming

    • High-speed Fiber Wi-Fi

    • Washer and dryer

    • Luxury well-appointed furnishing and artwork

    • Reserved parking space for one vehicle

* this link will take you to a secure portal to reserve dates and submit payment information*

What guests are saying:

  • Our stay at the Lighthouse Suites Collection was nothing short of magical. The suite was elegant yet cozy, the location was perfect for exploring Key West, and the hospitality was top-notch. We loved having a glass of wine on the private balcony in the evenings after a day of adventuring. If you’re looking for the perfect blend of luxury and local charm, look no further!

  • My partner and I booked this suite for a romantic getaway, and it exceeded all of our expectations. The ambiance was serene, the decor was stylish, and the little details (like plush robes and premium toiletries) made it feel like a boutique hotel. The best part? We were walking distance from everything but still had a peaceful retreat to return to. Highly recommend!

  • This was hands down one of the best vacation rentals we’ve ever stayed in. The hosts thought of everything—fluffy towels, a stocked kitchen, and even local recommendations that made our trip extra special. The bed was incredibly comfortable, and the space was filled with thoughtful touches that made us feel at home. If you’re visiting Key West, this is the place to stay!

  • Wow! Staying at the Lighthouse Suites Collection was an absolute dream. From the moment we arrived, we felt like we were in a tropical oasis. The suite was impeccably clean, beautifully decorated, and had everything we needed for a comfortable stay. The location is unbeatable—just steps from Duval Street, yet peaceful enough to enjoy quiet mornings with a cup of coffee.